| Pos | Name | Team |
| QB | Rodgers, Aaron | NFC |
| QB | Brees, Drew | NFC |
| QB | Brady, Tom | NE |
| QB | Manning, Eli | NYG |
| QB | Tebow, Tim | Den |
| RB | Rice, Ray | Bal |
| RB | Foster, Arian | Hou |
| TE | Graham, Jimmy | NFC |
| TE | Gronkowski, Rob | NE |
| QB | Smith, Alex | SF |
|
| Pos | Name | Team |
| QB | Brady, Tom | NE |
| TE | Gronkowski, Rob | NE |
| QB | Brees, Drew | NFC |
| QB | Smith, Alex | SF |
| TE | Davis, Vernon | SF |
| WR | Nicks, Hakeem | NYG |
| QB | Manning, Eli | NYG |
| RB | Sproles, Darren | NO |
| TE | Graham, Jimmy | NFC |
| WR | Colston, Marques | NO |
|